Inductees by Sport
| Inducted | Name | Class of | Sport |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2020 | 2014 Girls Soccer Team | 2014 | Soccer |
| 2014 Softball Team | 2014 | Softball | |
| Brooke Stulga | 2014 | Softball | |
| Emily Gaither | 2014 | Soccer | |
| 2019 | Haylee Beck | 2012 | Softball |
| JJ Witherow | 2012 | Football | |
| Melvin Mitchka | 1966 | Basketball | |
| 2018 | Mike Diedrich | 1973 | Track and Field |
| Anthony Franc | 2012 | Wrestling | |
| 2012 Girls Soccer Team | 2012 | Soccer | |
| 2017 | Alec Andrewson | 2012 | Track and Field |
| Haley Hatalla | 2011 | Volleyball | |
| Austin Newsom | 2008 | Soccer | |
| 2016 | 2010 Girls Soccer Team | 2010 | Soccer |
| Brandon Ringler | 2010 | Track and Field | |
| Aryn Newsom | 2010 | Soccer | |
| Allie Newsom | 2010 | Soccer | |
| Cory Blanchette | 1992 | Coach | |
| 2015 | Jake Emerson | 2002 | Coach/Soccer |
| 2007 Boys Soccer Team | 2007 | Soccer | |
| 2009 Girls Soccer Team | 2009 | Soccer | |
| Carla McQueen | 1990 | Volleyball | |
| Jodi Miller | 1990 | Volleyball | |
| 2014 | 2005-06 Boys Basketball Team | 2006 | Basketball |
| Jayme Absher | 2006 | Basketball | |
| Tyler Baldwin | 2006 | Basketball | |
| Cody McCullough | 2007 | Cross Country/Track | |
| John Nelson | Friend | ||
| 2013 | Anita Raymond | 1989 | Volleyball |
| 1995 Softball Team | 1995 | Softball | |
| 1996 Softball Team | 1996 | Softball | |
| Ross George | 2007 | Wrestling | |
| 2012 | Andrew Frame | 2006 | Golf |
| 2006 Golf Team | 2006 | Golf | |
| 2011 | Jeff Meyer | 2003 | Baseball/Basketball |
| Jill Cavender | 1984 | Softball/Volleyball | |
| 2010 | Colleen McQueen | 2004 | Track and Field |
| Bob Reed | Friend | ||
| 2009 | Nick Skolasinski | 2004 | Wrestling |
| Judy Mann | 1962 | Friend | |
| Larry George | 2005 | Wrestling | |
| 2008 | Courtney Russert | 2001 | Soccer |
| TJ Lambert | 1998 | Softball | |
| Krista Lambert | 1996 | Softball | |
| Mike Laninga | 2003 | Football/Track | |
| 2007 | 1974 Baseball Team | 1974 | Baseball |
| 1994 Baseball Team | 1994 | Baseball | |
| 1999 Girls 800m Medley Relay | 1999 | Track and Field | |
| Mindy Farmer | 1983 | Coach | |
| 2006 | 1985 Softball Team | 1985 | Softball |
| 1999 Boys 1600m Relay | 1999 | Track and Field | |
| 2005 | Allie Williams | 1999 | Cross Country/Track |
| Tiffany Greenley | 1999 | Track and Field | |
| Russell Peterson | 1999 | Track and Field | |
| Ken Wenzel | Coach/Friend | ||
| 2004 | Bill Asdell | Coach | |
| James M. Quigley | 1992 | Baseball | |
| Jim Rilott | 1954 | Basketball | |
| 2003 | 1987 Volleyball Team | 1987 | Volleyball |
| 1988 Volleyball Team | 1988 | Volleyball | |
| 1989 Volleyball Team | 1989 | Volleyball | |
| 2002 | 1953-54 Boys Basketball Team | 1954 | Basketball |
| 1954-55 Boys Basketball Team | 1955 | Basketball | |
| Nelson Grant | 1919 | Track and Field | |
| Tim Hamann | 1986 | Cross Country/Track | |
| 2001 | 1990 Golf Team | 1990 | Golf |
| Dave Shimanek | 1975 | Basketball | |
| Walter Addems | 1917 | Track and Field | |
| 2000 | 1977 Cross Country Team | 1977 | Cross Country |
| 1978 Cross Country Team | 1978 | Cross Country | |
| Ron Dodge | Coach/Friend | ||
| Cal Meyer | 1943 | Coach/Friend | |
| Ken Klipp | 1967 | Coach/Track | |
| Pam Phillips | Coach | ||
| 1998 | Virgil Guimond | 1936 | Track and Field |
| 1997 | Bob Reed | Friend | |
| 1984 Volleyball Team | 1985 | Volleyball | |
| 1996 | Carla McQueen | 1990 | Track and Field |
| Jodi Miller | 1990 | Track and Field | |
| 1989 Girls Track Team | 1989 | Track and Field | |
| 1989 Girls 800m Medley | 1989 | Track and Field | |
| 1990 Girls 800m Medley/800m Relay | 1990 | Track and Field | |
| 1990 | Tod Huddlestun | 1982 | Track and Field |
| Brian Stauffenberg | 1984 | Track and Field | |
| Doug Pelehowski | 1981 | Cross Country | |
| Scott Wenzel | 1987 | Basketball | |
| 1989 | Eddie Reed (1st Inductee) | Manteno's #1 Fan |